Is the tide finally turning for Turkey? Three months after the re-election of Recep Tayyip Erdo臒an for his third term as president, which听many feared听would lead to economic chaos, ratings agency Moody鈥檚听听that Turkey鈥檚 credit rating is on course for an upgrade.
Since the election, Erdo臒an听听a new economic team with a commitment to reintroduce conventional monetary policies after years of a more singular approach. This has yielded some early positive results, with June recording the first听听in 18 months 鈥 meaning more money came into the country than went out (mostly due to tourism and lower energy imports).
Meanwhile,听听has been attracting surging interest from foreign investors, and the听听against the risk of the government defaulting on its debts has sharply declined. So what鈥檚 going on?
The mess
When Erdo臒an won the May election,听, it extended his tenure as prime minister and then president to almost 20 years. This five-year term is likely to be his last, due to his deteriorating health and constitutional constraints. Thanks to the economic debacle that he created himself, it is also likely to be his most challenging.
There are two pillars to Erdo臒anomics: the 鈥渦northodox鈥 view that high interest rates cause inflation rather than the other way around, and a fixation on keeping rates as low as possible. It became much easier for him to implement after becoming听, which gave him much more power.
Central bank governors who have disagreed with Erdo臒an鈥檚 agenda听听shown the door, most notably Naci A臒bal, who was sacked in March in 2021 after only four months in office. It was the next governor, 艦ahap Kavc谋o臒lu, a former MP in the ruling party and columnist in a pro-Erdo臒an newspaper, who put Erdo臒anomics into overdrive. Turkey experimented with aggressively cutting rates at a time when inflation was already close to 20% and most central banks were tightening.
Official inflation skyrocketed to over 80% and the听lira plummeted, forcing the central bank to sell substantial听听to try and shore up the currency. The current account deficit widened to a听听in January and听听in February further worsened the situation.
Turkish inflation and the falling lira
This all happened despite the fact that the authorities struggled to impose their interest rate cuts on the wider economy. Whereas normally high-street interest rates move in line with the central bank rate, Turkish banks responded to the central-bank rate cut by increasing rates on consumer and business loans and savings accounts, signalling they didn鈥檛 think the central bank鈥檚 policy was sustainable. Loan rates for businesses only later came down after the听听a capital boost in the run-up to the election.
The interest rate divergence
A new approach?
The president has now taken a different path. He has appointed former investment banker听听as finance minister. 艦im艧ek is respected by the markets due to a听听managing Turkey鈥檚 economy between 2007 and 2018. He has vowed to return to听, announcing: 鈥淲e will prioritise macro financial stability.鈥
Another reversal signal has been the appointment of听听as the first female governor of Turkey鈥檚 central bank. She too comes from investment banking, having formerly been managing director at Goldman Sachs and co-CEO of First Republic Bank in the US. She has no central banking experience, but听听her appointment. She has an outstanding resume compared to her predecessor, Kavc谋o臒lu.
Erkan hiked rates on June 22听, the highest in nearly two years. The听听expressed a clear view that this is the way to reduce inflation.
The lira has nevertheless听, while听听rose from 38% to 48% in July. But along with the other improvements I mentioned at the beginning, there has also been a听听in foreign exchange reserves, indicating that the central bank is under less pressure to defend the currency.
In July, the markets were further reassured by the appointments of high-profile economists as听听for the central bank. This further听. On July 20, the bank hiked interest rates again,听.
What next
Raising interest rates may have side effects. Turkey has one of the world鈥檚 highest percentages of 鈥溾 that have only been able to stay afloat because of low borrowing costs, so there could well be bankruptcies. Also, we know from the recent US banking failures that rate hikes听听on banks by reducing the value of their bond portfolios.
Turkey鈥檚 banks are obviously not new to life under Erdo臒an.听听fine management teams and effective risk-management practices that are used to weathering the country鈥檚 economic storms. All the same, they look vulnerable because they hold听听that could be impaired by aggressive rate hikes 鈥 particularly since they are denominated in lira, which creates exposure to further currency collapses. The government could alleviate this concern by swapping these bonds in exchange for new high-yielding ones.
The bigger question is whether we鈥檙e really seeing the end of Erdo臒anomics or just a lull. We can鈥檛 rule out a repeat of 2021, when A臒bal was installed as central bank governor despite his orthodox economic views,听听shortly after. Erdo臒an has already put 艦ahap Kavc谋o臒lu, his biddable governor from 2021-23, in charge of Turkey鈥檚 banking watchdog, which doesn鈥檛 suggest a total break from the past and has confused markets.
The danger is that Erdo臒an won鈥檛 allow interest rate hikes in the run-up to the local elections in March 2024. On the other hand, voters in cities such as Istanbul and Ankara have been severely affected by inflation. They听听against Erdo臒an in the presidential election, having already handed metropolitan control to the opposition in 2019.
To regain these cities,听听tame inflation and alleviate the cost of living crisis. He may also be motivated by a desire to hand a better economy to his preferred successor (likely to be either his son or son-in-law), who might not enjoy his levels of popularity.
Whatever happens, much damage has already been done. The nation鈥檚听听is US$10,616 (拢8,335), well below its peak of US$12,508 in 2013 (albeit it has grown for the past couple of years). Turkey has lost significant numbers of听听to other countries.
Halting this brain drain, or even reversing it, will be crucial for future economic growth. This听听under Erdo臒an鈥檚 leadership. Avoiding a financial crisis is only the first step forward.